OotP: Snape as a halfblood (OotP spoilers)

saintbacchus saintbacchus at yahoo.com
Mon Jun 23 13:19:09 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 62046

Although the fact that Snape is apparently not on the tapestry is a 
strong point, I'm not convinced. Are half-bloods even allowed in 
Slytherin? IIRC, the Longbottoms aren't mentioned either; possibly 
Sirius was just trying to shrug off his ugly bloodline.

Also, like Hitler, Voldemort seems to value only those whose 
backgrounds are distinctly *different* from his. He wants to kill 
mudbloods, why would he confide in one? More likely he would resent 
seeing his own "weakness" toadying around him and simply kill any 
half-bloods who dared to try and join him.

Mr. Snape's abuse of Mrs. Snape could have many interesting 
ramifications that don't involve racial mixing. For instance, young 
Severus, feeling powerless to stop the abuse, could simply be taking 
his frustration on the only people lower on the totem pole than him -
 mudbloods. As a side note, my theory is that Snape's extensive 
range of jixes and hexes was acquired for the purpose of protecting 
his mother, but that he couldn't manage to do it.

Personally, I think Snape is basically a guy who felt totally 
powerless through most of his life, and was lured to Voldemort by 
the promise of power. Anyone want to supply a relevant Star Wars 
quote? :)





More information about the HPforGrownups archive