Sirius the Jerk

andromeda7_4 75211.522 at compuserve.com
Tue Jun 24 01:45:20 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 62598

Joan said:
> And I'm 
> very disappointed to find that Lupin such a coward. In a way, I 
found 
> the 15 years old Sirius and James was way over-the-stop more 
> disgusting and disturbing than Dudley, Draco and Snape combined. 
JKR 
> has successfully severed my respect for James & Co. in which  vice 
> versa won A LOT more sympathies for Snape (honestly after Umbridge, 
I 
> can't see how anyone can still find Snape a nasty bastard in 
> comparison. JKR IS amazing at writing annoying bitches and jerks). 



I thought Lupin's behavior sort of paralleled Ron's, when it came to 
confronting the Weasley twins.
Granted, Fred and George were far from behaving like the cruel 
bullies James and Sirius were; but yet they frequently broke the 
school rules, and every single time Ron ignored them and left them to 
Hermione to deal with.

I also have lost any respect for James and Sirius;  far from being 
upset over Sirius' death, I found I didn't much care and even felt a 
little cheated because of all the hype about the death of 
an 'important' character.

Andromeda






More information about the HPforGrownups archive