OOP: Marauder's Map, Overall Opinion

grindieloe andie at knownet.net
Tue Jun 24 22:24:22 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 63234

Two comments before I give my overall opinion: 1)I  actually 
stopped 
> reading and raised my eyebrows when I saw that Harry had 
possession 
> of the Marauder's Map.  It is a mystery!  How did he get it back 
from 
> Fake!Moody???  2) Couldn't Voldie have simply dropped some 
dungbombs 
> at the MoM and apparated in the DoM himself to get the prophecy?  
A 
> lot less work, huh?  However, guess that wouldn't make much of a 
> story!!! Thus, why I'm not JKR! :)
> 
> Overall, I think this book was fantastic!!! I loved it.  JKR 
> certainly has a gift with allowing us to feel what Harry is 
feeling.  
> Old questions (some of them) are answered and new, even more 
pressing 
> questions have been introduced.  Also, I think that while we are 
not 
> used to seeing Harry so angry, it was certainly inevitable 
> considering his constant circumstances.  He's growing up and 
> understanding completely all of the harships he has experienced 
and 
> will continue to experience.  Any teenager would question what is 
> happening in his everyday existance.  He is starting to vent his 
> anger... and possibly that may help him to defeat Voldemort in the 
> future... :)
> 
> grindieloe







More information about the HPforGrownups archive