OOP- Harry out of character-Too many holes- - **Spoilers**

[tanie_05]

No: HPFGUIDX 63358

shaggy6603 wrote:

<snip>

> Shouldn't someone be even just a tiny bit concerned that Harry has 
> used an unforgivable curse? 

tana:
I don't think anybody was really paying attention at the moment; 
there was pandemonium in the room from which Harry & Bellatrix left.  
I don't think anyone with the exception of Neville, Remus, & 
Dumbledore truly noticed that Harry'd ran after Bellatrix.

> I mean at the start of the book Harry is 
> nearly expelled (from distance) within like 10 mins of producing a 
> Patronus, yet no one bats an eyelid at him using the Cruciatus 
curse!
> (Yes, I know the "victim" deserved it)

tana:
I think I would have done the same & felt damn good after it was 
done...(blushes guiltily)
 
> but all the other books have 
> given the distint impression that the good guys always tried to 
> capture the enemy and would never resort to the unforgivable curses 
> because they're well, unforgivable.

tana:
Well...when the going gets tough, the tough get going.

> If you get expelled for using Magic outside Hogwarts (Self Defence 
> Excepted)How do they always get away with jinxing Malfoy and his 
> cronies on the train home?

tana:
The Hogwarts Express must be considered a safe spot since everyone on 
the train is a witch or wizard.

> Lastly who won the House Cup? I know it's trivial and Harry's not 
> that bothered because of his loss. But his disinterest could have 
> been used to highlight his grief.

tana:
I can only guess that wasn't Gryffindor.  At the end of the book 
Gryffindor had "a respectable amount" of points.  Wait, that didn't 
answer anything...sorry... :(

> I still thought it was a great book, just that the ending left too 
> many fundamental questions unanswered.

tana:
Okay, I'm gonna risk my neck here:  I felt like the book seemed a 
bit...confusing.  When I before I read OoP, I have a lot of 
questions, but now after I read it, I have more questions than ever 
before, unless that's how I'm supposed to feel...(sigh)

-tana, who is more confused than ever