[HPforGrownups] OOP : My review (spoilers)

[Melanie Black]

No: HPFGUIDX 63688

Imo_star wrote:
 liked that Ginny is actually starting to have more of 
character, but its a pity Hagrid wasnt killed off, as far as i can 
tell he would be no loss if he wasn't in the book at all, so hopefully 
the whole Grawp storyline will have some bearing on future books 
otherwise was it really necessary, I like the way Neville is coming 
along, in fact at the moment for me he is the character who is most 
interesting and believable.  Harry was as we know very angry and 
understandably so but he was very hard to like in this book and im 
sorry to say but comes across more lucky than anything else, 
certainly not particulary cleverly.

My reply:
 
I think the Neville storyline will have a lot more bearing in the future books.  I loved the character of Ginny.  I think we are shocked to see this evolution in her mainly because she was not in the other two books.  But judging by how the rest of her family is...it really that shocking that she is the way she is?
 
Also, I agree that Hagrid could have been killed off.  I mean it had no bearing on anything and I really didn't see his point in the book.  I think that JKR could of killed him...I know I for one would have much rather seen Hagrid die than say Sirius.  But that's just me
 
~Melanie


---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
SBC Yahoo! DSL - Now only $29.95 per month!

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]