Discriminatory admissions process (Re: OOP: Sorting hat's song)

[darrin_burnett]

No: HPFGUIDX 63694

Tim:
> 
> Notice, too, that there were no Slytherins in D.A.  Does this mean 
> that until we get a Slytherin on Dumbledore's side, Hogwarts will 
> never be truly united to stand against Voldermort??
> 


Assuming Snape is a Slytherin, there is one, apparently. But, the 
current crop of Slyths don't have anyone who is ready to jump 
sides... so far.

And as I said in another post, I'd like to see what happens the first 
time a Slyth shows up for D.A. class. I hope there aren't knee-jerk 
cries of "discrimination!" and "unfair!" when Harry and the rest are 
suspicious of that kid. 

Harry would be a complete idiot to blindly accept a Slytherin into 
that class. The Slyth will have to prove loyalty, just as Snape did.

As for the question of Snape being the Good Slytherin. I'm not sure 
what the hell Snape is (part of what makes him interesting.)

As I've said before, there are still enough signs out there that 
would make it possible for Snape to betray Dumbledore. For now, he 
seems on the right side.

Of course, as others have pointed out... there are theories for Evil!
Lupin, Evil!McGonagall, Evil!Molly and even Turncoat!Ron. 

So, until Evil or Good rear their heads, Snape is indeed a "Good 
Slyth." (assuming he was a Slyth.)

Darrin
-- Proponent of the Evil!Lady Who Passes Out Sweets on the Train 
theory, myself.