Dumbledore didn't tell EVERYTHING - Harry is related to Dumbledore

M.Clifford valkyrievixen at yahoo.com
Thu Jun 26 01:53:02 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 64020

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "gammac2003" <gammac2003 at y...> 
wrote:
> Hi everyone! I'm new!I had to get some theories out so here goes!
> 
Valky(me):
Hi Jenny welcome to HPFGU!!!
> Dumbledore could not have lived so long without at least one love 
of 
> his life. 

Valky again:
I have often considered this topic myself. Dumbledore certainly is 
too lovable a character to not have had some close relationships in 
his youth. There may be a far back kinship with Harry. DD is 
certainly fond of the boy, no doubt.



> 
> Harry will not die because the prophecy states one must die so 
that the other may live - no way is anyone going to allow V to 
survive. 

Absolutely in agreement with this. the prophecy states that somebody 
survives, IMHO this definately is a reference to all three people 
Harry, Vlodemort and Neville. One of them survives for sure and one 
thing we can count on is that our two young Gryffindors will stop at 
nothing to be sure it is not LV. Whether the final understanding of 
the prophesied defeater of the Dark Lord is that it is Neville, 
Harry or even a combination of them both one thing is for sure, 
neither will leave to chance that the wizard world be left with 
Voldemort.

> Harry may however have to find a way (or by accident) to go to the 
> veil to obtain something important that has been lost.
> 
> Sirius will leave Harry a Legacy.
> 
Nice thought. I am suspecting you are right.

>Hermione will take up with Fred George to discover a cure for 
>Werewolves.

Valky;
Me thinks a little wishful thinking. Though I don't put it past 
Hermione to be a discoverer of amazing new things as a graduate i am 
not so sure it is in Fred and george to devote themselves to this. 
However the possibility that Hermione wil be inspired by the 
inventiveness of the boys is not out of the question.



 and this is were Ron will 
> finally become aware that Hermione means more to him that just a 
best 
> friend. 

Valky:
I think it will happen sooner than Hermione inventing.



Hermione & the twins will be successful in the end and Remus 
> will finally be able to have a real life. He will return 
eventually 
> to Hogwarts as Defence against the Dark Arts teacher. He will have 
> Tonks with him.
Valky:
I like but am again fearing it is wishful thinking.

> 
> Remus becomes very fond of Tonks in the next book as he  is 
> designated Co-ordinator at Headquarters. Tonks is assigned to work 
> with Remus because of their shared Dark Arts abilities and because 
> she can cope with him when the full moon comes (because she is an 
> Metamorphmagus).
> 
Valky:
NICE SHIP!
I like very much Tonks is cool and cheery natured. I couldn't think 
of a nicer companion to wish on dear Lupin. Who is also cool and 
cheery natured in spite of his obvious disadvantage.


> Harry will become less angry with the world,but more withdrawn and 
> serious. Remus Lupin will become a key person in Harry's life - as 
> chief mentor,friend and teacher.

Valky:
I am finding it hard to believe this, sorry. I am thinking the 
introspective Harry is a likelihood, but relating more strongly to 
Lupin as a parental figure I doubt.
Harry is just the right age to go making assumptions that he brings 
bad news on those he loves. He is not going to allow Lupin anywhere 
near as close to him as that. and Harry will be in hot pursuit of an 
answer to the mystery of death anyway, since his destiny is that, in 
esscence.
So I see him leaning a lot more strongly to someone who understands 
that perhaps even Proffessor Binns.



 As Ron finally recognises his 
> feelings for Hermione, Harry will be shattered to realise his 
> feelings for Ginny - whom he comes to respect and care for more 
> deeply. He will alienate her as much as possible in order to 
protect 
> her, so that V can't find out and use her.He becomes a master of 
> occlumency to protect all those he loves.

Yes Yes and almost yes.
Ron will sweeten up Hermione and Harry will notice his heart for a 
girl and hate it because it puts her in danger. I think Harry 
already is a master of Occlumency. All he ever needed was the will 
to tell Voldemort to go away.
In OoP Harry feels he's getting the news he needed from Voldemort 
and the fact that he knew Voldemorts mind was an advantage to him 
Occlumency was just another way people could keep him in the dark. I 
think he will not only master how to tell Voldemort to go away but 
also when to.
He will, yet, not fear Voldemort being in his mind but instead be 
more discriminating of what he listens to.



> 
> Ginny is growing up rapidly. She is becoming more of a full 
character 
> in the books. She has always been the one for Harry. She has had 
> direct experience of V, is intelligent, brave and a Weasley. She 
> realised early on that she would have to bide her time and so has 
> calmly gone about making her own way - beside him rather than with 
> him until recently. Harry will eventually acknowledge Ginny and 
will 
> find a home at last.

Valky:
Nice way to put that SHIP a "home" at last. Again I like. We all 
still have the hope of a warm happy home for Harry and someone to 
say I love you.

 > 
> Snape will die saving Dumbledore (and in so doing, saving Harry)
> 
> Petunia will, still under sufferance 'do the right thing' until 
she 
> is killed off or something and Harry's reason for remaining at 
Privet 
> Drive will be no more.

Valy:
Snape will show himself as loyal to Dumbledore and Harry will 
finally forgive him. I hope in the same moment someone is able to 
convince Snape to forgive James, and Snapes future either in WW or 
beyond in the next adventure won't be so painful.
Petunia does seem to be hanging by a thread doesn't she... hmmm


 Harry will not return to Privet Drive after 
> book 6. Dudley will become vastly improved due to the scare he 
> received after the Dementor attack.

Valky :
There you go wishful thinking again Dudley improved. I agree that 
Privet Drive is making its exit in the next book though.
  
> 
> Both Harry and Neville will finish Hogwarts with their Auror 
training acceptances in their hands but Neville will eventually 
return to Hogworts as Herbology Teacher.

Valky:
You have the happy ending all wrapped up don't you.:b
I dont think Neville and Harry will finish their schooling the 
slightest bit interested in Auror training. They are both going to 
have a much larger kettle of fish before them.

>Arthur will become Assistant to the new Minister for Magic, 
Kingsley Shacklebolt.> 

Valky:
I like and it does make some sense.

> Bill/Charlie/Crookshanks will have a greater role in the next book 
> and Percy will redeem himself in the eyes of his family but will 
> never return to the fold.
>
> Slytherin will be disbanded.
> 

Valky:
Longshots IMHumbleO. But interesting to see.

> Lunar is an interesting character and will play a greater role in 
> future.

Valky:
No Doubt. She is also pretty tough. Taking on the DE's the way she 
did and barely getting puffed. 
> 
> Harry will seek a way to kill  Voldemort without actually doing it 
> but will be unsuccessful.

Valky:
Likely, we will see Harry try all possibilities to avoid being a 
murderer shy of copping out altogether.


Sorry couldn't think of a lot to say to all the rest. All good 
plausible stuff really.
Happy re-re-re-re-read.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive