OOP : SPOILER: Loose Ends?

hogwarts_online_school daniel at the-ministry-of-magic.co.uk
Thu Jun 26 18:48:35 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 64416

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "zihav" <lynch at a...> wrote:
> Hi:
> 
> Just finished reading the OoTP and wondered if anyone else felt 
that 
> there were several loose ends not explained. For example:
> 
> o Umbridge escapes - Why? She put the dementors on Harry and 
doesn't 
> get nailed for it. Not to mention the way she behaved at the 
school.
> 
> o DA - Will they continue the group? This will be in the next book 
I 
> suppose.
> 
> o Grawp. I assume Dumbledore knows, but what will happen. 
> 
> o Harry's Temper - He was is in a pretty bad mood most of the 
book. I 
> was assuming this was becasue he was picking up Voldemort's mood 
and 
> it wasn't really him, but nothing was said about this.
> 
> o Ron gives Hermione perfume - Harry gives her a book, but it's 
> obvious Ron likes her but nothing in the book about it. Talk about 
> moving slow...
> 
> o Ginny - Lots here, we also find out she's pretty powerful. She's 
> one of my favorites in the book.
> 
> There's more I sure. Just wanted to see if anyone else saw any of 
> this too.
> 
> -T


- Umbridge escaped because Dumbledore saved her. I was satisfied 
with not knowing what happened to her in the Forest, it didn't 
intrigue me much.

- I hope the DA will continue. The Sorting Hat adviced for all 
houses to unite and the the DA did that (with the exception of 
Slytherin). I'd like to see more meetings, but with Umbridge gone 
I'm not sure there will be.

- I think Grawp will almost definitely make more appearances. He is 
adored by Hagrid and he could prove a useful weapon again Voldemort.

- I think Harry's anger was his own, and not a chain reaction from 
Voldemort. There were a lot more problems in Harry's life in OotP 
and along with hormones I think it's only natural that he was 
angrier.

- I agree that Ron and Hermione's relationship is coming along very 
slowly. But I do think it is developing. There were little hints in 
the book here and there. Look at Hermione giving Ron a kiss on the 
cheek for example. His reaction shows that there is still something 
there.

- I was also interested in Ginny's character. I initially thought 
that JKR was featuring her more because she was planning on killing 
her off. But now she's gone back to liking Harry again I'm afraid 
that she'll come across as shy again.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive