[HPforGrownups] Re: OOP Dumbledore
Kimberly Dawkins
kim.dawkins at charter.net
Fri Jun 27 21:03:56 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 65117
On Friday, June 27, 2003, at 03:34 PM, pippin_999 wrote:
> --- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Kimberly Dawkins
> <kim.dawkins at c...> wrote:
>> SPOILER SPACE:
>> [
>> [
>> [
>> [
>> [
>> [
>> [
>> [
>> [
>> [
>> [
>
>> I have been wondering what kind of precautions Dumbledore
> took during his talk with Harry to ensure Voldemort couldn't
> appear inside Harry as he had earlier. All year long,
> Dumbledore wouldn't even look Harry in the eye for fear of this.
> The one moment he did just before Harry and the Weasleys
> took the portkey in his office, Voldemort appeared immediately.
> So why not during this rather long discussion near the
>> end of the book? What had changed?<<
>
> Remember that Harry could feel Voldemort's mind when
> Voldemort was feeling something strongly. In the same way,
> Voldemort was using Harry's emotions to enter his mind. This
> was why Harry was supposed to calm himself during practice
> with Snape and empty his mind of emotion before resting. Harry
> never got the hang of that. However, Harry's "heart," as
> Dumbledore calls it, the depth of his ability to love, is so
> repellent to Voldemort that if Harry fills his mind with it,
> Voldemort cannot possess him.
>
> Pippin
>
Me again;
Yes, but what makes Dumbledore think that Harry is now accomplished
enough at keeping Voldemort out so that they can have their
chapter-long conversation about "everything"? Is he assuming that
Voldemort will not try to re-enter Harry so soon after he was thrown
out by Harry's "heart"? Or did JKR choose to ignore the possibility of
Voldemort returning in Harry's mind so soon so she could let Dumbledore
have his chat and end the book?
I'm just curious why Dumbledore and Harry can now have this very long
talk without apparent shielding against Voldemort? Or or we to assume
that Voldy can no longer possess Harry after the event at the Ministry?
Kim (who suddenly realizes she should have read all those posts about
Harry and possession)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive