OOP-Narcissa Spy--Spoiler

[Debbie]

No: HPFGUIDX 65199

"Gabe" wrote:
> An idea that struck me this morning--
> 
> Many have been posting that there's likely a DD spy in Voldemort's 
> ranks (or at least close enough to know what's going on).  
Basically, 
> LV has used this enough, it just makes sense that it would be 
> paralleled from DD's side.
> 
> Many have also said that Snape might not be trying to ingratiate 
> himself to V, but that he has some other responsibility.  
> 
> Snape has also been around Lucius a lot, being called Lucius' 
lapdog.
> 
> Get this--What if Snape is getting info from Narcissa that he's 
> passing on to DD?  What if Narcissa's the "spy"?  Or, she's the one 
> that Snape is trying to convince to come over to DD's side?
> 
> I mean, we don't actually *know* what happened between 
> Kreacher/Narcissa/Lucius, do we?  We only have speculation. . .

Me:
Hmmm... you are right. We don't know for sure what happened with 
Kreacher. And if he went to Narcissa, she would obviously have to 
tell Lucius or else Kreacher would realize she's a spy and rat on 
her. It's an interesting theory that I haven't considered seriously 
before. I like it that Snape is getting info from her. Boy would 
Lucius lose it!

Personally, I just hope she's as evil as her husband. :-)

As for a spy.... why do we think there is one? I read about Tonks and 
my first thought (and still is) SPY! Is there some info I've missed 
that's in OoP where we know there is a spy? I'm just used to reading 
between the lines with JK, but have no proof. And considering I read 
it in 12 hours, there are definitely things I've missed. But for some 
reason, I keep thinking about Tonks being evil....in a Quirrell way.

-Debbie