Question about the Adult Women in HP Life

ugadawg02 ugadawg02 at yahoo.com
Sat Jun 28 02:45:45 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 65285

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "ymekelly" <ymekelly at y...> 
wrote:
> I have two questions and one comment about the adult women in 
> Harry's life.
> 
> Question:  1. Why doesn't Harry every wonder about his mother the 
> way he wonders about his father?  She is the one that gave her life 
> so he could live.  He seems to put that in the back of his mind and 
> focus on his "Dad".
> 
>           2.  And, we all know about his Godfather BUT what about 
> his Godmother???? Where is she? Why isn't she trying to play a role 
> in his life?
> 
> 
> Comment:
>       It seems to me that the women in Harry's life neglect him 
> (Aunt P) die (his Mom) or mother him from a far (Mrs. Wessley).  I 
> know that boys idealize their fathers but I think Harry needs a 
> Mother figure.

Maybe this theory is lack of sleep combined with a head cold, but I 
am starting to wonder if either Aunt Petunia or Minerva McGonagall 
could be Harry's Godmother. I skipped the obvious Mrs. Wealsey choice 
because it would seem a little too obvious especially with how she is 
already treating him like one of her own children. Perhaps Aunt 
Petunia since she was Lily's Sister as Sirius was James's best 
friend, or Minerva as someone Dumbledore might suggest as a good 
protector of Harry. As I said maybe these are strange ideas but I am 
interested to here what others ting of one of those two perhaps being 
Harry's Godmother. 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive