[HPforGrownups] OOP: Re: She wouldn't---would she?---SPOILERS!

[goingoutsleepwalking]

No: HPFGUIDX 65550

Keith said
> Don't forget the other little piece of evidence pointing to Harry's
> death:
> The divination teacher Trewalney (sp?) keeps insisting on seeing
> Harry dying an early death. Now that we know she actually produced
> something legit (THE prophecy) doesn't this make her other
> predictions hold more water?


I say

Rereading the scenes in which Trelawney makes her pridiction should make
it very clear that *everything* about her *real* predictions is *very*
different from her strutting around telling Harry that his death is
impending.  Dumbledore also makes it clear that she is generally full of
crap and has only ever said anything worth listening to twice now.

goingoutsleepwalking