OOP: Dobby apparated/disapparated in Hogwarts?!
origamiwizard
origamiwizard at yahoo.com
Sun Jun 29 11:05:08 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 65635
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "John Hatch" <john at s...> wrote:
> It's possible Dobby moved from one part of the castle to another -
although I believe that's probably impossible too. Perhaps he made
himself invisible.
>
> However, I'll add another comment to the mystery (or perhaps its
just a filk): Unless I'm mistaken (I don't have the books in front of
me) Harry refers to apparating and disapparating as a soft popping
noise. A soft popping noise and a noise that could be mistaken as a
car backfiring seem like hardly the same thing. In OotP, the noise is
so loud neighbors stick their heads out the window. Yet when Percy
apparates in GoF, or when Fred and George apparate in OotP, behind
their mother's back, the noise doesn't seem to be as loud.
Explanations? Or is the volume of the noise simply a plot device?
>
> John
Perhaps the noise level is relative to the sophistication of the
wizardry or wizard him/herself? I hesitate in saying that because I
have an inkling that Dobby and the house elves' powers will somehow
play a vital role in the outcome of the "war" that is looming.
OrigamiWizard, who is relieved that her silly question was not AK'd
outright, and that others were even patient enought to reply.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive