"Re: hearing voices" <-- imagined? & text of the voices

[redandgoldlion]

No: HPFGUIDX 53256

Hello everyone, 
   As far as Harry's memories go, *I'm* not even exactly sure where I 
stand. I did post that I thought Harry had remembered the green light 
from AK before he talked with Hagrid
Finwitch posted in reply:
...> Even before -- Harry remembered the green light, lying in his 
closet, 
> each night trying to reach as far back as he could. He *assumed* it 
> had something to do with the "car accident" that killed his parents.
> ...
  Thanks for pointing that out; I couldn't remember for the life of 
me. Later she posted:
> He did. And I, too, believe that the 'dream' was a memory. A memory 
> that also helped him to trust Hagrid... Yes, Harry *does* remember 
> his past - or has *visions* of it. After all, he has had visions 
> about future (Buckbeak in Crystal Ball, Triwizard Cup in dream 
before 
> he knew he was entering) and present (of Voldemort ending with his 
> scar hurting, at least I presume it was *present*. So why not past? 
> Either Harry remembers because he's held on to it - or he has a 
> *vision* about his past...
> 
> -- Finwitch
   I'm glad someone else thinks Harry isn't imagining it; I felt so 
alone. :-) Also, in Finwitch's reply, she mentioned Harry's seeing 
Buckbeak as one of his "future visions." Perhaps I mis-read, but I 
always got the impression that he was making this up. Didn't he say 
something to the effect of remembering what Ron said about making his 
exam vision up and doing the same thing for his test? That just gave 
me a thought, though! What if he *did* see Beaky escaping, but just 
*thought* he was making it up - a sort of subconscious vision. Well, 
that's all I have to add. Sorry my attempts to keep my posts pithy 
never work...
   Any more thoughts?
   ~redandgoldlion~