Ron is Dumbledore?

[Melody]

No: HPFGUIDX 53257

Greicy wrote about a Ron!Dumbledore:
> Will Ron die if Dumbledore die?  I mean it maybe different timelines
> because Dumbledore went back in time, but it's still Ron!
> Dumbledore.  It would be cool to *see* that in non-canon reference
> (aka theatres), to see Dumbledore dying while fighting Voldemort and
> a split screen comes up where we Ron just falling over for
> absolutely no reason what so ever!


Actually that would be cool, but if it is Ron going back in time to
become Dumbledore then it is impossible.  You see, Ron never split
persons.  When Ron went back in time, Ron was no longer in present day
classes with Harry Potter.  He was no longer there.  When he went back
he is now living his life as Dumbledore.  Meaning that even when he is
born later, he (in a way) died when he went back in time and did not
come back.  If Ron!Dumbledore died then "Ron" is dead.  But he would
not die as PresentDay!Ron.  That Ron is not linked to Ron!Dumbledore
except in the future.

Am I making any sense?

Look at this from this way too.  If PresentDay!Ron died, then
Ron!Dumbledore would have never come into existence.  It is in fact
the same person.  If PresentDay!Ron was to die, then Ron!Dumbledore
would cease to exist in history.  Period.

Not that this blows the theory out of the water at all.  In fact, I
find it most amusing.  For if Dumbledore really is Ron, then MD
becomes even more plausible you know.  For Ron!Dumbledore *does* know
who Scabbers is.  He does see the benefits of a freed servant of
Dumbledore, flawed potion, and how to work it to his advantage.  He
even knows that Quirrell has Voldie attached to his head.

One thing though, Ron!Dumbledore knows that Moody is Crouch.  So he
just lets Barty play his charade and get the flawed potion to come
about?  Let's Cedric die?  Seems a Ron!Dumbledore could find some what
to make Cedric spew slugs or something to keep him from getting that
cup.  I know, I know, he could not change the future, but he could act
less surprised by Barty's acting job.  Dumbledore was rather furious.
 Maybe Ron!Dumbledore was caught up in the moment.

Hmmm, Ron as Dumbledore.  Given Ron's reputation to date in the
series, seems Dumbledore does not have to be so squeaky clean now.  In
fact, that could cover a few of MD's dark spots you know.
*Dumbledore* may not of manipulated all, but a Ron!Dumbledore.  Well,
he is *there* to manipulate it all.  Though, what is he manipulating?
 Ron, when he went back in time, already knew what all had happened.
He cannot change anything.  So, what would he be doing as Dumbledore?
 Hmm, I think I am lost here somewhere.  Oh, well.  No big surprise on
my part I guess.

One more tiny thing: If *I* were Ron and went back to become
Dumbledore, well I would get such a kick out of watching myself.  I
mean, not too often you get the chance to see yourself from the
outside like that.  I think I might of even trailed myself.  Been my
own stalker.  Hehe.  Takes a lot of intelligence and patience, to
leave yourself alone like that.  Let you make your mistakes.  I mean,
look at what parents do to kids sometimes to keep them from making
mistakes.  How much would you protect yourself from it if you *knew*
it would happen?  But then again, it had to happen or Ron would not be
the way he was then, so....oh this is a vicious circle.

And as for Alberforth?  Well, when Ron took over as Dumbledore, he
accepted on Dumbledore's family.  He had all those years to learn
about dear old Alber and his goat.  And I bet after the Weasleys,
Ron's eyes might of been a bit big seeing a family like the kind
Dumbledore probably has.


Melody