(Catching up) Re: Lockhart's books

GulPlum hp at plum.cream.org
Thu Mar 6 01:44:57 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 53260

Maria wrote:

>In CoS ( i have the British hardcover), we read in page 38 that in
>Harry's letter from Hogwarts his list of books includes Lockhart's
>"Wandering with Warewolves". But in page 78, Lockhart himself tells
>the class that if they had read his book "Weekend with a Warewolf"
>they would know what his ideal birthday gift is.
>
>Is this a FLINT? Or are they different books?

Having been away for the weekend and been otherwise engaged since my 
return, I'm a bit behind, and it's possible someone else has said this 
(though I can't find it under the present subject header), but my 34th 
edition Bloomsbury *paperback* has "Wandering with Warewolves" in both 
cases (same page numbers).

So it would appear that it was indeed a FLINT, corrected once the paperback 
came out (or at least after the hardback edition you own).

Good observation, Maria. I've not seen that one mentioned before!

--
GulPlum AKA Richard, who knows it's off-topic for *this* list but would 
point to http://plum.cream.org/HP/misc/poafilming.htm for an explanation of 
at least one of the afternoons he was away from home, and why he was so 
busy yesterday.
:-)






More information about the HPforGrownups archive