FF: Transfer students (was: Harry not a seeker)

Anne urbana at charter.net
Sat Mar 8 23:08:00 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 53461

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "nobodysrib" <nobodysrib at y...> 
wrote:
>> Of course, we don't know if transferring schools is allowed since 
we 
> have not seen it happen before (I giggle when I think of Krum 
lining 
> up with all the other first years, waiting to be sorted), and there 
> may be canon showing Krum was a 7th year in GoF (which makes his 
> interest in Hermione a bit creepy and pedophiliac-ish, IMHO...).
> 

We haven't seen students transfer between wizarding schools in HP 
proper (yet), but we see it happen often in HP fan fiction. Usually 
the transfer student is a Mary-Sue or a Gary Stu, very often from the 
United States. Personally I haven't read any HP fan fics featuring OC 
transfer students that I've really liked, but that's probably just my 
own preference. I've tended to like adult OCs much more (e.g. 
Napoleon Jones in Paradigm of Uncertainty and its sequels; Raven 
Mordent in the as-yet-incomplete Darkly Inclined).

Anne U
(wondering if there's a filk about Mary Sues to the tune of Peggy 
Sue...)








More information about the HPforGrownups archive