Ron is Dumbledore?

[btk6y]

No: HPFGUIDX 53506

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Andrea <ra_1013 at y...> wrote:
> --- Kathryn Cawte wrote:
> > At this point his knowledge of the future becomes totally 
useless to him
> > (because things have changed so much) but he carries on trying 
to do
> > what he thinks is best for the ww.
> 
> ...But the entire point of the Ron!Dumbledore theory was to 
explain how
> Dumbledore seemed to know all of these things that he *shouldn't* 
know,
> unless he lived them as Ron.  
> 
> 
> Andrea


Me:
-Plus, with that theory you would lose the recurring loop that is 
needed for time to continue.  If the New Ron grows up in a world 
where Voldemort is defeated by Harry, why would he decide to go back 
in time? Even if he did decide to go back in time for some unknown 
reason, he would meet both the original DD AND Ron!Dumbledore- there 
would be no recurring loop like there is in PoA b/c the 
circumstances that caused Ron!Dumbledore to go back in time no 
longer exist.  Hope that wasn't too confusing...

Bobby