Ron!Dumbledore
piskmiffo
piskmiffo at hotmail.com
Sun Mar 9 12:31:47 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 53511
Gulplum:
<snip>
to rely on the Time Turner to resolve the series would be like,
> >way too easy.
<Well, Time-Travelling!Ron doesn't *resolve* the series; all it
resolves is
> how come Dumbledore seems to know so much about what the Trio are
up to.
> The beauty of it is that every objection to Dumbledore's refusal
to "fix"
> things can be simply explained by his knowledge that he can't (or
at least
> *shouldn't*) change what he knows to have occurred.
>
Me:
Yes, that is what I had in mind. The main character of the books *IS*
Harry Potter, and I'd bet 20 horses on him staying the main
character. The reason I can see why Ron!Dumbledore would exist, is to
SAVE Harry, so that he can defeat Voldemort. And I do NOT believe
that Ron!Dumbledore was the one who stopped Voldemort killing Harry
Potter as a 1-year-old. I want to believe he did that all by
himself. ;)
And I can't see why Harry should be less of a main character just
because of Ron!Dumbledore helping him instead of a None!Dumbledore
(okay, that was bad :P). He gets help all the time. Without
supporting characters, there wouldn't even be a Voldemort to defeat,
and what a sad place it would be then.
Gulplum:
> Don't worry about it. I don't think any of REDHEAD ALWAYS's
supporters
> actually believes it's going to come true, but it's terrific fun
> nevertheless. :-)
Me:
I think it's a theory that works, hehe.
But, I do not think (I REALLY HOPE THOUGH!!!) that the path JKR has
chosen is this one.
Here's some more stuff to add to the dough.
>From The Connection Interview:
http://www.sugarquill.net/forum/index.php?
act=ST&f=6&t=2073&s=8742fd7ea668b82ffe761cd5725f1aa3
Teacher: Anyway, it's very exciting. We just love Harry Potter. We're
curious ---- well first of all we can't wait for Books 4, 5, 6 and 7.
But after that, we're curious as to whether Harry is going to have a
life after Hogwarts, or if maybe, Harry might be a Hogwarts teacher.
JKR: Well, because all your kids said `hello' so nicely in the
background there, I am going to give you information I haven't given
anyone else and I will tell you that one of the characters, one of
Harry's classmates, though it's not Harry himself, does end up a
teacher at Hogwarts. But, it is not, maybe the one you think, hint,
hint, hint. Yeah, one of them does end up staying at Hogwarts, but ---
-
Radio Guy: Do the kids want to guess at it, Kathleen?
Teacher: Do you guys have a guess as to who it is?
(Kids shouting in background) Ron
Teacher: They say Ron.
JKR: No, it's not Ron. I can't see Ron as a teacher. No way.
--------------------
Now, this could be taken as it's anyone except Ron, and that would
mean that the WW and Hogwarts will indeed exist after the end of book
7.
But as I see it (well, I want to see it), it could mean that, since
Ron changes his name to Albus Dumbledore, "Ronald Weasley" is never a
teacher at hogwarts. Ron!Dumbledore was still one of Harry's
classmates, even though he changed his name. Then he would also fit
into almost all of the books. I myself consider knowing that one of
his classmates becomes a teacher AFTER the books end is pretty boring
info. :P
Oh, and now for something else:
Could Lockhart be part Veela?
/pisk
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive