Harry & Hermione Siblings?

[theultimatesen]

No: HPFGUIDX 53515

Christine:
> So the quill writes down the names of magical children
> at birth.  I tend to think that there is something
> else to this quill.  JKR may not have told us
> everything about it.  So this is my theory:
> 
> The quill writes down the names of the children *as
> given* at birth.  It has some magical property that
> keeps track of the children, so if their name changes,
> the quill *magically* knows, and the name the quill
> records originally changes too.  McGonagall wouldn't
> know if this happens; she doesn't look ahead ever.
> 
> Also, if a magical child moves to Britain, the quill
> takes down that name too.  Once again, McGonagall
> would never know.
> 

me: 
We've been told the same thing about the Sorting Hat. There's more to 
it than sorting. 

I do think however, that some of the professors know 
about Harry & Hermione (if in fact it is true). In COS when 
McGonagall comes to get Harry and says "yes I suppose you should come 
too Weasley". If she was merely coming to get Hermiones *friends* to 
let them know, why exclude Ron? Ron is *obviously* one of Hermione's 
running buddies. 

To me, it sounded like the tone when teachers get 
when they call you out of class when something bad has happened 
family wise. I could be wrong and I'm so open for other 
possibilities. I just happen to think this could be true (if it 
weren't for that darned Star Wars feeling hanging over my head). I 
just think that Hagrid, McGonagall & Dumbledore (if not Snape also) 
would know if Hermione was Harry's sister. 

Sen