REDHEAD ALWAYS Timeline (Was Re: Ron is Dumbledore?)

[Catlady (Rita Prince Winston)]

No: HPFGUIDX 53545

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Risti" <pretty_feet51 at y...> 
wrote:
> 
> That said, the one problem I have with the theory is the seeming 
> continuum of the dragons blood uses.  In their first year, the trio 
> learn the uses, presumably as a result of Dumbledore discovering 
> them.  For Ron!Dumbledore to later discover them as a result of 
> learning them seems to break some kind of time law in my opinion. 
> I can handle a person who has gone back shaping history to how it
> is now, but I can't handle discovering something only because you 
> were first taught it.
> 
But that has been the plot of some science fiction novels, making the 
point that time travel doesn't make sense to our brains.

> I propose this mainly because I don't like the idea of 
> the original Dumbledore dying off in some way. 

I like the variant in which Ron goes back in time, encounters the 
real Aberforth Dumbledore and is adopted by the Dumbledore family, 
possibly being given the name "Albus" by them for some reason -- 
after an ancestor, or because he was dipped in white paint, whatever.