No: HPFGUIDX 53808 Carrie wrote: > My thinking is Dobby, Winky, Lupin or Sirius. Just want to make a clear, clarifying post. Lupin can't die, because Rowling has stated that he will appear in later books, and will be an integral part of book seven. Dobby, Winky, and Sirius are up for grabs, though (I don't want Dobby or Sirius to die!). Night All. Brittany