Could Dumbledore Really Be Evil?

[grace701]

No: HPFGUIDX 53964

Katherine wrote: 
>"He said my blood would make him stronger than if 
>he'd used someone else's," Harry told Dumbledore. "He said the 
>protection my-my mother left in me-he'd have it too. And he was 
>right- he could touch me without hurting himself, he touched my 
>face." 
>For a fleeting instant, Harry thought he saw a gleam of something 
>like triumph in Dumbledore's eyes. But next second, Harry was sure 
>he had imagined it, for when Dumbledore had returned to his seat 
>behind the desk, he looked as old and weary as Harry had ever seen 
>him."
 
Giselle wrote: 
>Well Katherine IMO Dumbledore may obviously know something 
>that we don't. Perhaps LV having Harry's blood in his veins 
>is a weakness. Dumbledore may be able to use it as an 
>advantage in the war against LV. We just have to sit around 
>and wait to see what happens. 

kozmoz4 wrote:
>You know, I had wondered quite a bit about the twinkle in 
>his eye and I do not think that Harry got it wrong. Why I don't 
>think he got it wrong is that because Harry tends to believe that 
>people are mainly good. His parents are murdered, he lived with a 
>horrible step family for ten years, people distrust him in every 
>possible occasion and still he does not give up on the good in 
>people. I mean he could have been a class A paranoid, but he isn't. 

>That's what that twinkle means, Voldemort can be defeated. 
>God I love Dumbledore, triumph implies planning, he could very 
>possibly have planned all this, or at least saw it before hand! And 
>don't forget the first prophecy, it maybe about Voldemort's defeat 
>and it might include Harry. We may be seeing the prophecy coming 
>true. 
>(Of course we will if Rowling continues to write, but you know what 
I mean)
 
 
Lea:
>This is something I've wondered about since the first time I read 
>it.  I believed instantly that Harry was NOT seeing things and that 
>Dumbledore really did have a twinkle in his eye.  Now that 
>Voldemort is carrying Harry's blood, he has opened himself to a 
>weakness, which of course he doesn't see yet.  
 
>My first thought was that the weakness is LOVE, since that is the 
>magic that Harry carries in his veins from his mother. In Harry's 
>case the Love is his strength, but we all know that "love hurts" 
>and now Dumbledore knows there is a way to get at Voldemort - 
through the very blood in his veins.  Harry's blood may have helped 
bring Voldemort back to life, but in the end I believe this will 
also prove to be his undoing.  Of course we'll have to wait and see 
what JKR has to say about all this!

>Oh yeah, and my 2nd thought on this matter - how will they be able 
>to use this new information against Voldemort?  Hmm...  maybe a 
>little chat with our Potions Master might be the catalyst to get 
>something brewing?
 

Maybe when Harry experiences love hurting, say when that significant 
person dies in OoP, Voldemort will feel Harry's pain, the loss of 
losing someone you love, and perhaps guilt because I'm sure Harry 
will feel guilty from now on when a loved one dies.  Voldemort will 
feel think that he is putting Harry in a vulnerable position to know 
when he is most weak and who makes him weak.  Yet not knowing that 
he, too, is putting himself in that vulnerable position.  Making him 
human, which he doesn't want to be, and weaker.  IMO, this will kill 
him, slowly, but unknowingly.  If there's a way for love to kill, 
that is.

Greicy