This can't be the chamberpot room

[siriuskase]

No: HPFGUIDX 54075

It is highly speculated that the chamberpot room would be very
important in this story.  But putting Rowlings remarks about Harry
returning to a special room with magical qualities together with
Dumbledore's joke just doesn't make sense.  I mean nothing she says
implies that these are the same room.  And now we see a "third"  room
that people are trying to tie in somehow.   In my opinion, there are
three completely separate rooms:  chamberpot room, room that Harry
returns to, and the ghostly candle room on the OoP cover.  I don't see
any reason to think that any of them are the same room.  If Harry has
ever been to this round lit with dark candles room before, it isn't
mentioned in the books, and I sure don't see any chamberpots.  And
Harry can't return to the chamberpot room anyway, he didn't go there,
Dumbledore did and Harry only knows about it from Dumbledore's remark.

QED, three separate rooms.  But I do want to see the Chamberpot room,
it would be a nice change from visiting a girls bathroom, that gag is
getting old.

Sirius Kase