Some questions about Sirius Black (some FF)

nobodysrib nobodysrib at yahoo.com
Sun Mar 23 00:01:18 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 54137

Briony wrote:

> I have read rumours that Sirius will return to Azkaban, and Harry 
> goes to save him.  <snip> In another fanfic, the Dementors are 
> removed behind Fudge's back, and replaced with giants.

Or even, since dementors have been known to ally themselves with 
Voldemort, they are removed from their posts and replaced by Giants.  
Either way, this could be a great way to set up an interesting 
situation: Harry goes to save Sirius from the guarded-by-giants 
Azkaban... and who better to bring with him than Hagrid, Hogwarts 
Embassador to the Giants.  But during a scuffle, Hagrid is killed.  
(Which leaves Harry dealing with *twofold* guilt - (1) not saving 
Hagrid, and (2) Hagrid's life being sacrificed in an attempt to save 
Sirius - which could leave Harry wondering if he chose one trusted 
friend's life over the other.

<snip> 
 
> [question about imprisoned DEs]

This makes me wonder about the Dementors desire to keep these DEs in 
Azkaban if dementors are potentially allied with Voldemort.  Doesn't 
this set it up to make it easier for these DEs to escape?

And a question of my own:

If Sirius is re-imprisoned, why would he need Harry's help to break 
free?  (He's already proven he is able to escape on his own.)

- Nobody's Rib (who hopes that Crookshanks will eat Beetle!Rita 
Skeeter)





More information about the HPforGrownups archive