scars

finwitch finwitch at yahoo.com
Wed Mar 26 10:13:55 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 54346


Felinia:


> 
> And that's a tag remark I'll insert here:  JKR tends to use a 
building to 
> exaggeration, often in threes, which is a fairly common literary 
device (and 
> one I use myself in casual conversation) - sometimes in 
Dumbledore's 
> remarks, which people then seem to take seriously.  For example, 
this is not 
> a "triple whammy" example - but Dumbledore's scar that is a map of 
the 
> London Underground...casual throwaway line, and I really don't 
think it's 
> meant to go anywhere and be anything profound - just humorous that 
> Dumbledore would notice such a thing.  :-)
> 
> Felinia

Yes well - but it *does* say something of Dumbledore: He knows all of 
London Underground to say that. It also allows "scars can be useful" 
and Harry's scar definately IS useful. Third person having (useful?) 
scars is Alastor Moody. I wonder what Moody's scars tell him, what 
alarm-bells they are (which would explain Fudges comment of having 
heard about curse-scar-alarm-bells before, particularly as Moody is 
considered as being paranoid).

Supposedly Harry will meet the real Alastor Moody somewhere - St 
Mungos? Diagon Alley? Hogwarts? Azkaban? Hogsmeade? - and discuss 
scars. There's something about Harry's scar...

And Sirius... I do hope he'll *finally* be free!

-- Finwitch






More information about the HPforGrownups archive