Secret Keeper
greatlit2003
hieya at hotmail.com
Thu May 1 04:35:28 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 56690
Hi everyone..I noticed something unusual in PoA...Sirius said that
the Potters had switched their Secret-Keeper at the last minute...we
were led to assume that they did this because Sirius was an easy
target for Voldemort (it was well known that he was close to
James)...but, Dumbledore later told Hermione and Harry that he had
testified to the Ministry that Black had been the Potters' Secret
Keeper (during that frantic conversation in the hospital wing).
Dumbledore DID NOT KNOW about the switch. Why would the Potters keep
something so big a secret from him unless they suspected that he was
not as good as he seemed? Why didn't they use him as their secret
keeper? I wonder whether the switch was because of the threat of
Voldemort or Dumbledore. Sorry if this has been discussed already.
I'd love to hear your responses anyway.
greatlit2003, who loves Dumbly-Dorr until he's proven guilty
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive