dumbledore question

[Aaron Crowe]

No: HPFGUIDX 56705

Lisa XX wrote:
Has anyone thought about the possibility of Dumbledore
being on Voldemorts side? I mean, In GOF, when Harry is looking
at the Pensieve, Dumbledore recalls SNape saying that "It's
coming back.. Karakoff's tpp... stronger and clearer than ever..."
meaning the dark mark (p.517) and Dumbledore merely says " A connection
I could have made without assistance, but never mind". 

COuld this mean that Dumbledore is a double-agent, having the dark mark
himself and so being able to see it himself? Could Voldemort NOT be
afraid of him, or be afraid of him because he is in CONTROL of
Voldemort? Or is Voldemort not afraid because they are on the same
side? I just wonder what people think of this idea. The ambiguous state of
the characters goodness and evilness is quite blurred, so could it be
possible? I look forward to some reactions, if it hasn't already
been said!
-------------

ME: This idea of DD being on Voldemort's side I'm not
sure is substantiated by the plots of the books. Why
would DD not have aided LV in his previous attempts at
reincarnation? He certainly had ample opportunity to
just give LV a bit of aid in PS/SS, PoA and CoF and LV
would have been back a lot sooner. As for the smile he
gives at learning that LV can now touch Harry,
personally I think that is because he knows that LV is
now mortal and can be killed for good. I'm sure a lot
of that will come to light in OoF since DD mentions to
Harry that he will explain everything.

I think DD is the only person Voldemort is afraid of
because he knows that DD was able to defeat Grimwald
and is more powerful.

-Fr. Crowe, Ravenclaw Adherent


__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
The New Yahoo! Search - Faster. Easier. Bingo.
http://search.yahoo.com