Quote from GOF

addictedtobass2003 katie.jarvis1 at ntlworld.com
Fri May 2 15:50:41 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 56798


> On Friday 02 May 2003 14:10, jeanico2000 wrote:
> > "You stand, Harry Potter, upon the remains of my late father", he
> > hissed softly, "A muggle and a fool...very like your dear 
mother..."
> > I was just reading GOF again to refresh my memory and get ready 
to
> > move on to OOTP and came across this sentence that Voldemort 
speaks
> > to Harry in the graveyard. Why does he compare Lily to his 
father?
> > was Lily a muggle? I thought Harry's parents were a wizard and a
> > witch. Any thoughts on this? Maybe I am just not understanding 
the
> > quote properly.
> > Nicole

I think that he is referring to the "fool" part of the sentence.
He then goes on to say that in death, they both had their uses, 
which I think is a disgusting thing to say, but that's Voldemort for 
you.
I think that the parallel between Tom Riddle Sr and Lily Potter just 
adds more pain for Harry, because of her being compared to something 
so closely related to Voldemort.
It is definitely a very strange comparison, between a muggle and a 
witch - referred to as a muggle :S
Could it be a mistake?  Any thoughts?

addictedtobass2003
Katie







More information about the HPforGrownups archive