Subject: Re: OK... theory I read while I was gone

[kenneyjohn]

No: HPFGUIDX 56976

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "gishstar1" 
<gishdaydream at hotmail.com>
 wrote:
(should there be a snip here? i hope not, if so, sorry)
 That is SO wild!! 

Another really crazy and stupid theory I've had for a short time, 
until I woke up and realized how dumb it was... James' wand is good 
for transfiguration... SO! (and this is REALLY out there so bear 
with me) I think he transfigured Lily into a cat... a.k.a. 
Crookshanks, (I know, sounds stupid) and then the person that was 
really Lily was actually a cat... and now Lily is Crookshanks... Ok 
ok... so I think I just read a little to far into the story. Even I 
think it's a bird brained idea. 


The Key of Kenney thinks:

Like, yeah
 man
 this just might work! And when Voldemort comes to 
Kill the Potters, he comes up against a guy in costume and a cat, and 
somehow doesn't manage to kill baby Harry
 Wait a minute: maybe 
because Voldemort IS Harry! You can't kill your past self, coz if you 
did, you wouldn't be there to go back and kill yourself.


Yeah that's it: Harry's Voldemort, Lilly is a Cat, James is 
Lupin/Sirius and Hagrid's a mantelpiece.

It just makes that much sense!

>From the Key of Kenney
Who yesterday saw a poster sized image of the book 5 cover, attempted 
to steal it and was made to promise not to, so didn't. Dam.