OK... theory I read while I was gone

[Chuck]

No: HPFGUIDX 56984

Alison wrote:
> The main flaw in it -
> and it looks like a big one to me - is why has Lupin/James not 
taken any
> interest in Harry in the last 12 years?

The biggest flaw is: why does Lily say, "Your father's coming," at 
the end of Book 4.  Wouldn't the wraith that comes out of V's wand be 
Lupin and not James?  And wouldn't Lily know it?

Nice idea.  Doesn't hold.

Saw the book.  Pretty good.  Completely ignored the 
Lily/James/Emergence Order issue.  Fatal flaw for the level of 
analysis put in.

Not worth the cash.

Chuck