5th Person at Godric's Hollow

[alexcukier]

No: HPFGUIDX 57233

Hello Guys,

I subscribed the digest about 2 month ago, and finally I got some 
time (and courage) to post my ideas.
- I truly believe that James, Lilly, Harry and Voldemort were not the 
only person that tragic October 31st. Of course this ideas are not 
entirely new, and I'm sorry if this was discussed before.-
At PoA, Chapter 12 "The Patronus", Lupin says in a strange 
voice: "Did you hear James", to Harry. 
I don't know if this strange voice was because Lupin knows whose it 
was; if it was Lupin's own voice; or if Lupin "thinks" it was not 
probable that it was James (for some reason we don't know yet, but 
James could have already been killed by Voldemort at the door, or was 
hidding in a wardrobe, whatever...)
Other important thing that shows me that this is the right direction 
is: I don't believe that any of the alive characters that were at 
Godric's Hollow will disclosure the whole truth to Harry - Voldemort 
could give more details if it was important to him that Harry knows 
the details, I don't believe in Harry's memory either (he was only 1 
year old), and their fathers are definitely dead (according to JK's 
interviews).
I don't buy any time-travelling to Godric's Hollow too - it's 
impossible to Harry go there and not influence what happened. 
Other possible solution to the truth emerges would be by a Pensieve, 
but it would not be so interesting and exciting as a 5th person shows 
him/herself and tell all the details.
If there was a 5th person at Godric's Hollow, who could be? This 
person had an active role in what happened or was hidden? Maybe these 
answers are going to tie the plot and say some things:
- What happened to Voldemort's wand from October 31st to V's re-birth?
- How Harry survived to V's Ava Kedavra? (if it was that easy, like 
the Lillys love sacrifice, or hability with Charms, we can agree that 
it would exist at least ONE other person who survived to AK, wouldn't 
it? I don't believe it was that - maybe even voldemort doesn't knows 
the whole true about what happened there because maybe he was 
defeated before the end of the happenings)?
- Whose voice could be? Dumbledore's? Lupin's? In my opinio the voice 
is from someone's that Harry NEVER HEARD UNTIL his 15's...

I'd like to start some discussion about it.

Alex Cukier, a brazilian huge fan

Darrin, "Brazilian Boa Constrictor's Servants" would be a good band 
name?