[HPforGrownups] James Potter Dead????

[Richelle Votaw]

No: HPFGUIDX 57406

peggybaratto wrote:

> <snip Switched!James-Lupin theory>
>
> >Thoughts????

GulPlum AKA Richard, who thinks the theory stinks, for the record :-) said:

> I suspect most people who have an opinion have already said all they have
> to say on the subject, either over the last few days or the previous times
> this theory was discussed. :-)

Well, except for me.  I've had another thought, while listening to PoA in
the car today.  I also think the theory stinks, but I did have a thought
that could correspond.  Not too long after all the "You heard James?" etc.
from Lupin, in his next antidementor lesson, Harry asks about what's under a
dementors hood.  Lupin procedes to tell him no one really knows who can
actually say, but then says they must have a mouth because the jaws are
clamped over the mouth to suck out the soul.  Would it then be possible to
return that soul to another body?  Could two souls be switched and live on
in different bodies?  Believe me, I still don't buy into the Lupin/James
switch theory, but it made me wonder.

Richelle