James Potter Dead????

[theultimatesen]

No: HPFGUIDX 57411

peggy:
> According to Galadrial Waters (Wizarding World Press' Ultimate 
> Unofficial Guide to the Mysteries of Harry Potter:  Analysis of 
Books 
> 1-4) (yes, I've heard many complaints about this book, but...),
> she belives the real Lupin is dead.  James and he took an extra 
> precausion because and performed a switching spell.  If this is 
true, 
> James is Lupin still!
> If this idea is true, then much could be explained:
> 1) Lupin's "sudden motion with his arm, as though to grip Harry's 
> shoulder, but thought better of it".
> 2)why Lupin acted the way he did when Harry told him that he heard 
> his father's voice.  
> 3)how Dumbledore got Jame's invisibility Cloak, and Hagrid got the 
> key to Harry's vault. (SS-PS)
> 4) Why did Lupin say " now that we could all transform..."  Why did 
> he not say "that they could transform"?  (Ok this one is a shakey 
> stretch...don't werewolves transform?---but maybe!)
> 5) Remember your mythology?  Remus was the legendary wolf child who 
> was murdered by his brother Romulus?  hmmmm.


me:
I've read the Ultimate Unofficial book also. I loved it. I doubt JKR 
is going to bring in a "Romulus". I had had several reasons awhile 
back as to why the Lupin=James thing couldn't work(cold meds are a 
wonderful thing!LOL), but I cannot remember them all at this time. #1 
being JKR has said we will never see a live Lily or James. Granted 
there could be the loophole of "it's not *really* James.. It's James 
in Lupin's body", but I doubt it. As much as I'd love to let myself 
believe this, my mind is telling me not to for some reason. *crossing 
fingers for it to happen*

Sen