5th Person at Godric's Hollow

[jahanua]

No: HPFGUIDX 57415

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "mongo62aa" <mongo62aa at y...> 
wrote:
> Alex Cukier:
> 
> I truly believe that James, Lilly, Harry and Voldemort were not the 
> only person that tragic October 31st. Of course this ideas are not 
> entirely new, and I'm sorry if this was discussed before
> 
> <snip>
> 
> If there was a 5th person at Godric's Hollow, who could be? This 
> person had an active role in what happened or was hidden? 

regarding all the recent discussion, I believe there could have been 
a fifth person, or not.  If there was, I have no doubt there was only 
5.  Not many people knew where the Potters were.  The potters 
themselves, Dumbledore, Pettigrew, and sirius.  I don't think anyone 
else did.  I also do not believe this would be a secret Petigrew 
would tell Voldomort in front of anyone.  That would point to the 
fifth person being Petigrew, and there only being 5.  Sirius, came 
too late, or at least that is what he tells Harry.  I do not believe 
Snape knew where to find the Potters either. 

- Jahanua