Speculation on Tom Riddle's origins
jahanua
elmindreda8558 at aol.com
Fri May 9 10:17:34 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 57417
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Lissa B <lissbell at c...> wrote:
> > --- Lissa wrote:
> > > a long post that Harry Potter and Ginny
> > Weasley may be
> > > Tom Riddle's biological
> > > parents.>
>
Ok, since I have read all the responces, this has a little to do with
several. First of all, when relating Harry's living relations,
Voldemort may not be living, but the weasleys certainly are. If
Harry had a child with Ginny, and Ginny is living, that would make
them relations, even if not by blood. Also, if the weasleys are
decendants of slytherin, then Harry would be related to them this way
too.
Secondly, the quote where the word ancestor was used, while that
is simply the stupidest mistake I can think of, it does seem to be a
mistake. If Harry is Voldemort's dad, I still don't see how that
makes Slytherin his descendant. Slytherin lived more than a thousand
years ago, Voldemort was born about 70 years ago, and if Harry is
his father, he can not be Slytherin's ancestor.
Thirdly, can you immagine how many turns it would take on a time
turner to take you back 70 years, not to mention taking you back far
enough to be slytherin's ancestor?
Lastly, if Ginny is Voldemort's mom, then why doesn't he have any
weasley features? he doesn't look at all like a weasley, and why
would he want to kill his mom in cos, which also brings up the
question, if he couldn't kill his dad, how could he come so close to
killing his mom? He grew stronger as she grew weaker, it would make
more sence that he would also be erasing his life as she grew weaker.
I am not saying this theory isn't good, just that i have problems
with it. If you have anwsers to these questions, (especially the part
about killing his mom) i would love to hear it.
Jahanua
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive