The Dueling Club - an interpretaion

[peggybaratto]

No: HPFGUIDX 57701

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Ladi lyndi <ladilyndi at y...> 
wrote:
> 
> It's these two sentences that gave me the idea
> that the spell was Snape's idea. 
> 
> Lynn
I know that there is a whispering situation going on.  It just does 
not ring clear with me.  I also realize that the movie is very 
different from the books--but why is this scene acted so 
differently in the movie?  Snape almost seems concerned--ALMOST.  

If Dumbledore does in fact give Snape the idea (request, command 
(whatever)) to put Harry in a stressfull situation with a Snake---Oh 
forget it. Snape really screws up my thinking when it comes to these 
books.  I DON'T GET HIM.  I'm not sure if anyone does just yet.  Why 
would  Snape want people to think Harry was Slytherin's Heir? He's 
not  exactly the person that Malfoy would want to follow around (at 
this point anyway).   

In GoF why is it Snape that seems to be delaying Harry from telling 
Dumbledore about Crouch(mad in the forest)?  Arg...
The boy is driving this girl batty (forgive the pun).
If he is not a vampire, then I think he may at least be an 
aninmagus.  There are too many bat references for him not to be.  JKF 
did say that the animal a character will turn into is definitely a 
reflection of the character's personality.


~~~~~~~~~~Peggy