A Twist on Stoned!Harry

mongo62aa mongo62aa at yahoo.ca
Tue May 13 18:56:52 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 57782

annemehr:

My theory has the added attraction (to me, at least), that Voldemort 
defeats himself, without Harry, who has never killed anyone, having 
to kill Voldemort to save the WW.  There was a thread not so long ago 
where many of us expressed our distaste to the idea that Harry would 
ever kill.  And I just don't see him ever learning Avada Kedavra (not 
that that would be the only way one could kill someone).

Debbie:

My theory is that at the end of the last book, after Dumbledore has 
died, is that the Dementors kiss Voldemort. Kind of like in "The Lion 
King" when the hyenas kill their master, Scar. Although my thinking 
is that Voldemort puts a curse on Harry for them to kiss him, but 
either Harry repels it or it bounces off him and affixes to 
Voldemort, who loses his wand in the process so can't "fix" the 
mistake before he gets kissed.

This way, Harry still defeats Voldemort without killing him. Tidys 
everything up, huh?

Me (Bill):

I also have never liked the idea of Harry killing Voldemort at the 
end of Book 7.  Having Voldemort Kissed is one option; I was thinking 
that one of Voldemort's spells goes wrong, or bounces off of Harry 
and back onto himself, and he loses all of his magical powers and 
becomes what he hates, a Muggle.

So we have three options here (simplifying slightly):

1) V attacks Harry with spell; spell rebounds, kills V

2) V attacks Harry with Dementors; Dementors turn on V, Kiss him

3) V attacks Harry with spell; spell rebounds, turns V into a Muggle

Does anyone else have suggestions?  I am looking for ways in which 
Voldemort attacks Harry in some manner, but the attack goes awry and 
rebounds on Voldemort, leaving Harry's hands clean, and Voldemort 
harmless.

Bill





More information about the HPforGrownups archive