St. Mungo's not safe?

sabotage3p3 SaBoTaGe3p3 at hotmail.com
Wed May 14 00:58:42 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 57830

I was reading a Harry Potter book 1-4 analysis and because of it I 
realized that St. Mungo doesn't seem as safe as it looks.  The first 
time I read the books (the Harry Potter books) I thought it's 
probably a safe place because it's a hospital and most people see 
them as a safe place in my opinion.

In the books, it looks like that Lucius Malfoy has a lot of 
influence over the ministry.  So that could mean he controls a lot 
of the ministry.  He controlled the board of governors in Harry's 
second year, so this backs up that he probably has a lot of control 
over the ministry.

The next thing that the analysis made me think over was that he does 
a lot of contributions to St. Mungos.  At first I thought nothing of 
it.  But I thought why would he contribute stuff if he is not 
getting anything in return.  He seems a evil person and to me it 
looks like he would probably only do stuff for someone if they do 
stuff for him.

But these things were minor things and it didnt seem a big thing to  
until in Chapter 27 Page 522 in Goblet of Fire, it says:

"Harry scanned the story about Crouch.  Phrases jumped out at him:  
hasn't been seen in public since November...house appears 
deserted...St. Mungo's Hosptital for Magical Maladies and Injuries 
decline comment...Ministry refuses to confrim rumors of critical 
illness."

It says St. Mungo's decline comment.  Why would they decline a 
comment?  The only reason they may have declined a comment was if 
they were covering something up.  If he was sick or anything was 
wrong with him, they could of at least said that, he had some kind 
of problem and will not be in work for a little while.  They could 
of said decline comment to lead the people who are reading it that 
they have seen him.  That probably couldn't happen because he was 
under the Imperius or something, and/or Voldemort had him... I can't 
exactly remember.

Soo, to say the truth it looks like St. Mungo isn't safe but JK 
Rowling could of done that to lead us to believe that it isn't safe 
(you never know) and Lucius Malfoy contributed money so that his 
family and him could get special services.  

But if they are dark wizards running it, they could do anything.  
They could decline some wizard treatment or they could do the wrong 
thing to a good wizard.  You never know!


"sabotage3p3" 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive