E!Lupin wasRe: Dumbledore, Snape and Harry with a side of MD

[stephandra84]

No: HPFGUIDX 57901

Pippin Wrote:
> Impossible? Why? Because Dumbledore trusts him? Lupin's 
> own friends thought he was the spy. I can't believe it was solely 
> because he is a werewolf. 

I believe that this conclusion was more by process of elimination.
Sirius thought it was Remus who was the spy and vice versa, because 
both knew that it wasn't them and I think neither of them even 
considered Peter as a possibility simply because he was not as strong 
or as intelligent as the rest of his pals.  I don't think the 
werewolf factored that much into it at all, mostly the fact that 
Sirius couldn't fathom Peter as betraying them, else he wouldn't have 
offered him the role of Secret Keeper. 


Stephandra
A Newbie