Evil!mcGonagall (was: Hints for HP and the Order of the Phoenix! / Mistakes /

[innermurk]

No: HPFGUIDX 58242

Squee wrote:
> I just take this as one more piece of evidence that
> McGonagall is the "insider" that Voldemort mentions to
> his pack o' DeathEaters in GoF....
> 
> No one seems to be with me in my theory that she's the
> baddy, but hey, I perservere on my own....


If I'm remembering correctly (don't have my books with me) Voldemort 
says later in that passage that his "Faithful Servent" is the one who 
fixed the portkey for him, and we later find out that Crouch!Moody is 
the one who did that and is his faithful servent at Hogwarts.

So, it couldn't be McGonagall unless you think he has two faithful 
servents, or that he didn't know who enchanted the portkey.
I find it more likely that McGonagall is on the good side though.

Innermurk