[HPforGrownups] OOP: DADA teacher and others

[Becky Walkden]

No: HPFGUIDX 58361



 

Finchen wrote:

I don't think that Lupin would be a teacher at Hogwarts or even the headmaster for he himself quit in PoA giving as a reason that he as a werewolf woud be too dangerous towards the children (he says thins when Harry tried to persuade him to stay in Hogwarts, I couldn't quote the page for I usually use the german edition and most of the time the hearbook). 

Me:  I missed the post where somebody suggested Lupin would return as a teacher.  Your right of course.  He will never be a professor again although I'm sure he has more important tasks to perform yet.

Also:Fudge did not explicitly threaten DD to fire him. He only said he had to talk to him about the leading of Hogwarts in the future time. He also said in the same situation the DD had a lot of freedom to do waht e wanted. This could also mean that now Fudge would choose new teachers. 

Yours Finchen

ME:  Your also right about Fudge.  That is one of those statements that a whole lot of people I believe are taking way out of context.  First, I don't believe he would fire Dumbledore.  He respects him too much.  Although he MAY try or threaten to.  Which leaves part two.  I don't think he would be successful if he did try.  He doesn't run a one-may dictatorship here.  The school board probably has a lot more to say about it then he does.  Dumbledore ain't going anywhere.  Personally, I think that comment was really just a reaction trying to reassert a little control of the situation there where he was quite frankly feeling pretty darn panicky with everybody yelling at him that Voldemort is back and he not wanting to believe it.  This WILL cause a conflict I believe in the next book as it's totally unresolved but it won't cost Dumbledore his job.  Huggs Becky




---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
The New Yahoo! Search - Faster. Easier. Bingo.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]