A Harry Failure
Leah Jamison
ecprincess78 at yahoo.com
Fri May 30 18:56:14 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 58982
> And Melody wrote:
>Interestingly, it is a charge of arrogant, self-reliance that Barty,
Jr. qua Moody lays at Harry's feet. Harry had the key to the 2nd
task in his own bedroom, but, as Bart, Jr. points out, Harry was too
arrogant to ask for assistance from others. (And maybe too arrogant
to ask for the help of a near-Squib like Neville?)
Leah writes:
This was not the original intent of the thread, but I would like to
discuss the "too arrogant to ask Neville" possibility. I do not
think arrogance was a factor when no one asked Neville. Harry didn't
ask everyone for help, as was suggested somewhere-["I'd be asking
everyone I knew for help"] (I know that's not totally accurate-sorry
no canon at the moment). He only asked (correct me if I'm wrong) HR
and Sirius. Any other help with the tasks was offered freely. He
wouldn't think to ask Neville for help, because he never has before.
Leah, who should REALLY be working right now ;-)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive