[HPforGrownups] The Black dog

Anne Geldermann IrishMastermind at hotmail.com
Mon Nov 3 04:52:29 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 84012

Richard Parker said:
> Hi guys, not sure if this has been picked up yet, but Winston 
> Churchill once famously described his depression as 'the black 
> dog'. Sirius' animagus form is obviously a black dog. Thus, 
> Harry may slide into depression due to Sirius' death.


The black dog is a common occurence in folklore, especially in England.  The 
apparition, with many nicknames (including the Grim, Padfoot, but mostly 
(Black/Old) Shuck) is usually considered a bad sign, including the death 
omen it is considered in the books.  My guess is that JK and Churchill both 
got the idea from these stories.

It is probably a safe bet that Harry will continue to be depressed about the 
loss of Sirius, although I think he seemed rather depressed and angry 
through almost the whole of OOTP anyway.  What (if anything) do you suppose 
will snap him out of this funk?  He seemed a little better after talking to 
Luna.  Will he get better emotionally, or will brooding over the prophecy 
all summer plunge him further into Angstland?

Anne






More information about the HPforGrownups archive