Lupin's sense of humor (was:Re: TBAY: Evil! McGonagall Revisited )

[jwcpgh]

No: HPFGUIDX 84078

> --- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "jwcpgh" <jwcpgh at y...> wrote:
>  
> > I thought the Snape-boggart that Remus helped Neville create was 
> > classic, myself.  Maybe not a funny line as such, but definitely 
> > showing a sly sense of humor.

> > "K":
> Seems like a case for Evil-Lupin <g>. You know, the Lupin who 
stood 
> by while Snape was being bullied by James and Sirius. The same 
Lupin 
> who as a teacher at Hogwarts puts a Snape-boggart in a dress. Not 
> very classy. Especially coming from a man who knew what Snape had 
to 
> endure at Hogwarts. It's funny to the kids but not funny to Snape 
and 
> Lupin surely knew that.

Laura:

But if Snape really was Neville's worst fear, and if Neville had to 
make that fear laughable to make the boggart go away, what else was 
Remus supposed to do?  He couldn't tell Neville to get another worst 
fear, could he?  And if Snape is surprised to find that students he 
bullies fear him, then he's not as smart as we thought he was.
> 

> 
> ~not totally convinced dear Lupin is evil~
> ~not at all convinced McGonagall is evil~
> ~lover of the great Dumbledore~