Tom Riddle's Origins (was No Sex, Please)
pippin_999
foxmoth at qnet.com
Thu Nov 6 18:38:20 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 84227
> The Sergeant Majorette said:
>
>
> However, when you claim to be the most powerful Dark Wizard
in the world and that you're justified in killing hundreds of
innocent people and I paid 25 bucks for your latest adventure, I
want to see some serious motivation. I was way pi--, I mean
annoyed -- when the name that strikes terror into the hearts of
wizards everywhere turned out to be an anagram (could that be
more pre-teen?) and now he wants us to feel somthing
because his mother was cruelly abandoned? See the
chaplain, Private. Sounds like a personal problem to me.
>
> Now that Draco turns out to be an oxygen thief and a total
waste of other natural resources and Harry isn't cute anymore, I
see troubled times ahead for the franchise if Voldemort doesn't
step up to the plate and get more interesting.<<<
There are only so many ways in which people become
disfunctional. Corny as it is to say it, healthy people crave
relationships based on trust and mutual aid.
If the ability to trust is damaged, then the craving may turn to
other things: drugs or alcohol or relationships based on power.
Voldemort probably can't get over it, even if there were chaplains
in the wizarding world; he's too damaged. But paranoids can
make effective leaders; fear of a common enemy breaks down
the barriers between people, and paranoids are very good at
identifying enemies. Revealing Voldemort's childhood trauma
shows the reader what sort of person he is, and why he craves
power so much.
What's more interesting than Voldemort is why Harry, who' s had
the same experiences, doesn't turn out the same way. Granger's
article said that Harry lives in fear of the Dursleys. But that's not
true, IMO. Harry's never been afraid of the Durselys. They don't
make his stomach clench or his heart race, he doesn't have
nightmares about them or worry about what they'll do to him next,
he doesn't invent rituals to placate them.
In fact, it's the other way around. It's the Dursleys whose
adrenalin gets pumping around Harry, they angst constantly and
they have rituals: don't answer questions: don't leave Harry by
himself, don't say the 'M' word.
Pippin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive