Luna doesn't wear silk, and replies to other Luna threads

[Jen Reese]

No: HPFGUIDX 84307

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "dan" <darkthirty at s...> wrote:
> Annemehr's post, a very nice one, I must say, while alluding to 
the 
> alchemy interpretations of Luna's role, doesn't stop there, which 
is 
> good. But I wonder how effective her processing of her ostracism 
> really is? Or, rather, I should say, if there's any profit in it, 
for 
> herself? This would be my concern, with a RW person like Lovegood. 
> Then again, what would be the cost of piercing the shell, if it 
could 
> be done? The thing is, even thinkers like Annemehr can be taken in 
> wholly by Luna's appearance. As much as I love her, there is 
> something definitely wrong. If Luna is our passage to Potter, what 
> does that say about us?
> 

Jen: I don't understand what you mean when you say "with a RW person 
like Luna" and that there is something "defeinitely wrong" with 
Luna. You've alluded to the RW part before in other posts; are you 
writing a theory that includes information on your own thoughts? You 
seem to think all the posters so far aren't getting Luna "right" so 
I'm wondering your take on her in more detail.