house elves and apparation at Hogwarts?

kyliemckenzie1225 abush at maine.rr.com
Fri Nov 7 17:17:44 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 84319

in a previous post, samnanya remarked:

<snip><finally, 
You cant apparate in Hogwarts (its been said so many
times by so many different characters that I am
suspicious, but thats me)>

Now me(kylie):

This reminded me of a question I had while re-reading CoS.  While 
Harry is in the hospital wing regrowing the bones in his arm, Dobby 
appears for a second time.  When they are interrupted, we 
read " 'Dobby must go!' breathed the elf, terrified.  There was a 
loud crack, and Harry's fist was suddenly clenched on thin air."

We have read that this sound is supposedly connected to apparation, 
for instance, in Chapter 1 of OoP, after Harry is caught listening to 
the news, "Harry was sure that the cracking noise had been made by 
someone Apparating or Disapparating.  It was exactly the sound Dobby 
the house-elf made when he vanished into thin air."

so, my question is.....(okay, maybe I am missing something obvious, 
but...) are house-elves an exception to the rule that no one can 
apparate into or disapparate from within the grounds of Hogwarts?  Is 
there a different kind of magic (i.e., not apparation) going on 
here?  Can someone explain?  thanks!

kylie

p.s. thanks to erika for correcting my misquote RE:SHIP: movie 
contamination






More information about the HPforGrownups archive