OoP: What was the Point of this Death? And Phineas ??s

justcarol67 justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Sat Nov 8 19:34:24 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 84413

> > And I was also wondering, when did Sirius get another wand? And all 
> > the DE's that were in Azkaban too? I mean, the just couldn't waltz 
> in 
> > to Ollivanders. <snip>
> > >Luna 
> > > Marianne (List Elves: This is the way the post was signed)
> 
> 
(Katie Wible? This was an unsigned post)
> Umm, why couldn't Sirius just waltz into Ollivander's?
 <snip>

Carol:
Since he couldn't apear in diagon Alley in human form without being
recognized and arrested, Sirius would have had to "waltz" into
Ollivander's in dog form (I don't think you can apparate without a
wand) and then transform himself in front of Ollivander, still filthy
and penniless--which also raises the question of how he got the gold
to buy Harry his Firebolt since the goblins were unlikely to give
money to a wanted man--or a cat with a message and a vault key(?). As
far as the wand goes, maybe it wasn't his own. He could have found an
old one of his mother's in her house. Kreacher wouldn't have been able
to hoard it in his den (he gets around rules but can't actually break
wizard law).
 
Just some thoughts. And there's the old and ultimately more important
question that I don't think has been satisfactorily answered about 
how Voldemort got HIS wand back.
 
Carol, who has read the FAQ but not 100,000 back posts 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive