Wormtail's silver hand (was: Thoughts on Wormtail's activities in OOTP )

[Berit Jakobsen]

No: HPFGUIDX 84598

Carol wrote:
 
> Anyway, if Lupin's assignment of a vampire essay is the only clue, I
> think the theory is on pretty shaky ground. It looks like a red
> herring to me.

Me:

Also: If Lupin really did assign a vampire-essay to reveal Snape 
being one, Hermione would almost certainly know he is one, wouldn't 
she :-) But Hermione has never voiced any suspicions about it to Ron 
and Harry. I can't see why she would hold back information like that. 
She did with Lupin, but that was different since she believed he was 
inheritedly good. I know she chooses to believe Dumbledore who says 
Snape can be trusted, but would she keep a secret like Snape being a 
vampire from her best friends?

Berit